TIDAL ‘faux streams’: Criminal investigation underway over doable data fraud in Norway – Tune Industry Worldwide

In an explosive legend last year, TIDAL used to be positioned at the center of a foremost alleged ‘faux streams’ scandal.

Norwegian monetary newspaper Dagens Næringsliv said it had received an internal TIDAL company exhausting pressure which proved the streaming platform’s play-counts for two predominant albums from 2016 – Beyoncé’s Lemonade and Kanye West’s The Lifestyles Of Pablo – had been artificially inflated.

DN reported: ‘Beyoncé’s and Kanye West’s listener numbers on TIDAL had been manipulated to the tune of a lot of hundred million faux performs… which has generated extensive royalty payouts at the expense of completely different artists.’

TIDAL CEO Richard Sanders subsequently “rejected and denied” DN’s claims, nonetheless TIDAL opened an internal review into a doable data breach anyway. This review, introduced eight months ago and undertaken by a third-occasion cyber safety company, aimed to “aggressively [pursue] multiple avenues accessible to mutter what came about”. No results had been publicly published up to now.

Per DN’s legend, Norwegian series society Tono, which represents round 30,000 songwriters, filed an official police criticism against TIDAL.


At the present time (January 14) brings substantial data: Dagens Næringsliv has published that Norway’s National Authority for Investigation and Prosecution of Economic and Environmental Crime (Økokrim) has begun an investigation into doable ‘faux streams’ at TIDAL.

Økokrim’s Chief Public Prosecutor, Elisabeth Harbo-Lervik, confirmed that Norwegian authorities launched this ongoing investigation – aiming to mutter or disprove the suspicion of streaming quantity manipulation within TIDAL – within the autumn/autumn of 2018.

In accordance Harbo-Lervik, Økokrim’s inquiries are “aloof in an early stage”. Yet as a minimum four historical TIDAL workers had been interrogated earlier than a resolve as section of the investigation up to now, says DN, facing over 25 hours of questioning in total.

“We’re aloof looking forward to TIDAL to provide data that can [tell us] something a pair of doubtless manipulation.”

Elisabeth Harbo-Lervik, Økokrim

Of this community, experiences DN, three of us left TIDAL all correct now and concurrently within the 2d half of 2016: two held Industry Analyst roles at the platform, while the third used to be TIDAL’s Head of Industry Intelligence – accountable for examining streaming figures.

DN claims that, while aloof workers of TIDAL in Norway, this trio identified signs of manipulation relating to the linked Kanye West and Beyoncé albums; the community then contacted a legal legitimate earlier than informing TIDAL administration about their findings, after which an internal meeting used to be held.

All three folk subsequently resigned from TIDAL after signing what a DN provide calls “the gold traditional of confidentiality contracts”.


“[TIDAL] has previously acknowledged that they take into legend themselves to be insulted by [DN’s allegations, so the company] must always beget a vested passion in getting data on the desk that can [tell us] something a pair of doubtless manipulation,” said Harbo-Lervik to DN (translated). “But we’re aloof looking forward to them to provide this data.”

TIDAL’s legal legitimate, Fredrik Berg at the legislation firm Fend, commented: “TIDAL is at this time no longer a suspect nor has there been filed charges. We beget an ongoing dialogue with Økokrim. It might possibly perhaps well well well no longer be pretty to part the contents of this discussion with the press.”

TIDAL dad or mum Project Panther Bidco Ltd filed its annual accounts within the UK earlier this month (ogle below) for the year ended December 31, 2017. The Companies Home file confirmed annual income growth of 13% to $116.8m, alongside a reasonably diminished working lack of $forty.6m. (You might possibly perhaps well well well presumably also precise TIDAL’s beefy 2017 accounts by right here.)

In January 2017, Softbank-owned telco Speed got 33% of TIDAL for $200m.



In accordance to DN’s well-liked file into ‘faux streams’, as a minimum 320 million TIDAL performs all over each and each The Lifestyles Of Pablo and Lemonade in 2016 are believed to had been manipulated. DN interviewed person TIDAL subscribers who said there had been performs of these albums recorded on their accounts which they didn’t recognise.

DN extra reported that it had received acquire entry to to file company royalty cost experiences revealing that TIDAL paid Sony in device over $four million all over April and Would possibly perhaps perhaps of 2016. Of this, Lemonade – a Billboard 200 No.1 album – accounted for an estimated $2.5 million.

“TIDAL is at this time no longer a suspect nor has there been filed charges.”

Fredrik Berg, Fend

Likewise, primarily based completely on DN, in February and March 2016, TIDAL paid Standard a total of €3.2 million ($3.4m) . Of this, The Lifetime of Pablo approximately delivered approximately €2 million ($2.1m).

DN employed the NTNU’s Heart for Cyber and Recordsdata Security (CCIS) to forensically investigated the data it received on TIDAL’s performs. This file – which you are going to be ready to gather in beefy right here – concluded: “We beget by developed statistical diagnosis definite that there has in actuality been a manipulation of the [TIDAL] data at specific cases. The manipulation seems targeted in the direction of a extraordinarily specific self-discipline of track IDs, linked to 2 obvious albums.”


The Jay Z-led Project Panther Bidco got Norway-primarily based completely streaming service WIMP in 2015 for €50m, by the utilization of a buyout of WIMP’s dad or mum company, Aspiro.

WIMP used to be then rebranded as TIDAL. Founding artist shareholders of TIDAL incorporated Nicki Minaj, Rihanna, Kanye West, J Cole, Jack White, J Cole, Beyoncé, Coldplay, Jason Aldean, Madonna and Deadmau5.

Sources at the time that these megastar supporters were each and each given 3% equity in TIDAL in return for his or her public declaration of loyalty to the service. Kanye West later reportedly disassociated himself with TIDAL, claiming the company owed him $3m.

TIDAL has today targeted on its world enlargement, launching in areas in conjunction with Uganda and Brazil.Tune Industry Worldwide

Read More

Leave a Reply