attach the FA Cup? Manufacture it 7-a-aspect, 30 minutes every methodology –

Ship your suggestions to


Nowt sinful with the gorgeous frail FA Cup
Every to their very maintain however I take care of the FA Cup – though supporting the opponents’s most a success club does lend a hand.

Granted, some golf equipment don’t concern with it, the winner’s pot is minimal, it’s backed as we relate, and apparently handiest sizable golf equipment commit it to memory as we relate.

However in the opponents’s defence – it threw up some fundamental upsets with a alternative of Premier League groups biting the dust in the Third round, anybody can blueprint anybody gorgeous from the launch – now not like the Champions League, which map two wide golf equipment would maybe well also merely blueprint every diversified early on clearing the path from some smaller golf equipment, the opponents is launch to non league golf equipment and can offer them a in fact crucial funding pipeline if they can build a cup speed collectively and can imply these semi experts can reminisce about the day they played against Premier League superstars, it’s on terrestrial TV, and at closing it’s gorgeous a in fact gorgeous taking a search and is an accurate cup now not like that charlatan the World Cup.

Abominate the FA Cup whenever you need however don’t demand its extinction – a number of of us unruffled take care of it.
Graham Simons, Gooner, Norf London


Johnny have to be confusing the FA and League (or, whatever it’s known as) cups.

The FA Cup is the realm’s oldest club cup opponents and has gigantic gravitas across the realm.

It’s been a thread in my life. I’ve watched every individual since 1977 and can recite the ratings of most of them.

But, I’d fight to establish the First Division/EPL title winners of yearly since 1977.

Rising up, right here in New Zealand, it used to be the handiest English football match you may well watch live all 300 and sixty five days. It used to be the day even rugby gamers grew to turn into football followers.

It’s the closing indictment of our throwaway society to even propose binning the history and mana of the FA Cup.

The League (or, whatever it’s known as) Cup, on the diversified hand, has long been an irrelevance and is now merely a stepping stone for youth gamers.

Johnny is gorgeous being a romantic frail curmudgeon.

However, I accept it, because I’m one myself.
– Nige. Footy fan. NZ


John Nicholson hasn’t half purchased his balls in a blender over the FA Cup. There’s loads sh*t to battle through, I’ll want to strive and organise it a technique or the opposite.

John’s gripe: The FA Cup is sh*t for the reason that sizable groups don’t play their strongest eleven.

John’s hypocrisy: FA Cup is sh*t because Man Utd, Man Metropolis, Liverpool, Arsenal & Chelsea delight in acquired the FA Cup delight in acquired 21 of the closing 23.

You would maybe additionally’t delight in it each and each ways, John. It is vital to realise that if the complete sizable groups tried as hard as you’re announcing they want to then there is puny-to-no likelihood of any seeing vary in the winners. So which is it: half-strength-wide killings, or full strength giants by no map getting killed?

John’s gripe: The FA Cup is sh*t for the reason that prize isn’t rate winning for the sizable groups and it’s sh*t that it’s known as The Emirates FA Cup now.

John’s hypocrisy: The FA Cup is sh*t because handiest 10 of the 32 video games were played at 3pm on Saturday and it’s sh*t that the tip 20 groups in the nation delight in already purchased money.

Again, you may well’t delight in it each and each ways. The prize money is generated basically through TV offers and sponsorship. If the complete video games were played at 3pm on the Saturday (on terrestrial TV handiest, bear in mind) then there’d handiest be one televised recreation. The do does John think that extra income goes to come support from, if they’re handiest exhibiting one recreation per round on a non-industrial channel? And which sponsors are going to pay gorgeous money to promote their brands at video games if handiest the captive target market bodily at the last video games are the handiest ones that glimpse it? Highlights are all smartly and beautiful, however most video games are handiest going to accept 1-2 minutes of coverage, so the sponsors aren’t exactly going to accept their money’s rate there.

John’s gripe: The FA Cup is sh*t for the reason that media manufacture up wide killings an excessive amount of.

John’s hypocrisy: The FA Cup is sh*t for the reason that sizable groups are loads better than the puny groups now that they don’t want to play a full strength crew.

I imply, what? He’s whinging about the gap being wider between the tip flight and the diversified leagues, however then moaning that they aren’t in fact wide killings for the reason that sizable groups rested some gamers? How does that even manufacture sense? Most Premier League reserve groups would maybe well beat any crew that would class as being a capacity wide killer, so why have to that topic when the underdogs recall? I’d wager my bottom greenback that Newport County’s gamers and followers don’t think any much less of their recall because Kasper Schmeichel and Jamie Vardy didn’t play.

John’s gripe: The FA Cup is sh*t since it’s no longer what it old to be and VAR is sh*t.

John’s hypocrisy: The FA Cup is gorgeous sh*t and wants to be gotten rid of for something unique and alternate wants to be embraced.

So, John desires a cup that the followers love, and the TV audiences gorgeous want to suck it up? Accurate, clearly. Who attain you think those TV audiences are produced from, John? It’s also tantalizing that John goes to this point out of his methodology to counsel that we resolve a unique opponents however offers precisely zero perception to what this unique opponents can be love. This, undergo in mind, is from the creator of articles titled: “The truth: We have won nothing from the Premier League” and “A manifesto for rescuing the Champions League…” so I am intrigued to thrill in a look at what this modern unique opponents of his would see love, seeing as he doesn’t love any sleek ones.

The FA Cup is best; it’s no longer what it once used to be however that’s ok. It’s alright for bigger groups to leisure a number of of their gamers, particularly after a in fact busy festive length, as long as the gamers who take hang of to the pitch build in the difficulty. It’s alright that a crew a number of leagues lower then goes on to beat them and it will get known as an sizable killing; if anything else, it’s an even bigger deal now precisely on account of how a long way ahead the larger groups are. It’s alright for video games to launch at diversified instances because which map more folks accept to be aware more video games. It’s alright that the sponsors establish comes first: who, diversified than those paid to attain so, even mentions the be aware “Emirates” when talking about it anyway? It makes precisely no distinction to anybody.

In actuality, now it’s lustrous damn sure the do the pains lies. John: you’re the difficulty. You are going to have to thrill in it to be the an analogous because it used to be support whenever you occur to were a lad and this used to be all fields. And you opt this whereas bemoaning the complete ways that it has changed, but at the identical time as tell that alternate have to be embraced. Which is it: attain you opt it to alternate or no longer?

No, I think what you in fact decide is to flip support time. You are going to have to thrill in a full strength sizable crew to accept beat by a crew of plumbers and postmen from North Shields, at 3pm on a Saturday, whereas handiest a handful of other folks accept to be aware it from some dingy, muddy, shed of a ground in the north east. You are going to have to thrill in a wide crew to fully decide to a recreation whereby they’ll accept absolutely clattered by a bunch of lumbering idiots whose largest claim to popularity will be “I gorgeous caught on one Ozil in the FA Cup”. You are going to have to thrill in sizable groups to fully decide to video games for which there’s very puny to manufacture diversified than some frail common thought of romance or glamour, gorgeous so luddites love you may well also accept a exquisite warm feeling within.

John: you’re the difficulty. No longer the FA Cup, no longer the groups, no longer the gamers, no longer the followers, no longer the broadcasters. You. The FA Cup doesn’t need you, and whenever you don’t to find it irresistible to any extent extra then in fact be at liberty to sod gorgeous off.
Ted, Manchester


Accurate to thrill in a look at the annual moan about moaning about the FA Cup is alive and smartly this 300 and sixty five days again, particularly Johnny Nic’s opine that it used to be better in his day when all of this used to be trees. I in my thought take care of the FA cup, even supposing I am frail ample to preserve in mind it when it used to be it sounds as if fully salubrious and each recreation played out love an episode of Eastenders on Xmas day.

There may be some fact that the cup has been devalued, no question my crew (United) has contributed by playing weakened groups in the early rounds or no longer entering at all in 2000 even supposing we had acquired it the old 300 and sixty five days. Priorities delight in shifted, with the league and CL weighted loads heavier than the domestic cups on account of the monetary rewards linked to every. Nostalgia also plays a phase, every person can see support fondly to the previous with misty eyes and ignore the fact that a number of of the suits (and football) were awful support then too.

On the opposite hand, to merely take hang of the potential that it isn’t working so rip it up and launch again would exclusively devalue the 2d most crucial domestic trophy; we would maybe well also merely as smartly gorgeous do away with it altogether then. It is a stance which shows the wasteful instances we live in – don’t concern repairing, it’s gorgeous as low-tag to purchase a unique one. Some issues are rate preserving onto, the history of the FA Cup and its hyperlink to the cowl time is rarely any doubt one of them. It pre-dates the Premier League, has survived through wars and tragedies, has given us all memories (gorgeous and contaminated) and can continue to attain so if handled accurately. The do to start wants to be to discontinue devaluing the last and play the semi-finals somewhere diversified than Wembley.

Give the younger supporters the possibility to thrill in their very maintain FA Cup memories and add it to the list of memorable moments that we can all half and tag support on in years but to come support. Assassinate off the FA Cup now? Pah, definite it used to be handiest a number of years in the past we purchased no doubt one of the vital best FA Cup last moments – Corpulent Pardew’s cringe-inducing dad dance. Bought the moves love Jagger.
Garey Vance, MUFC    


Dear Mr Nicholson

In 2017 I used to be lucky ample to lend a hand the FA Cup last on account of my brother getting me a ticket. I saw my cherished Arsenal conquer Chelsea and unruffled delight in obliging memories to see support on. Every 300 and sixty five days when the Cup rolls round again I dream of but some other day day out at Wembley.

There are tens of millions of other folks up and down the nation who half this dream. I’m sorry you delight in turn into so bitter and jaded and appear to do no longer need any optimism for the opponents. Possibly it’s essential to see for but some other sport to utilize your time writing about as you appear to attain nothing however moan about football.
Ticket (FA Cup loving Gooner) 


fix it
I are mindful of it would by no map work in a thousand years however how about with the exception of Premier league groups from the opponents and giving the eventual FA Cup winners computerized promotion to the Premier league and all it’s budget?
Andy (AFC)


The FA Cup would maybe well also very smartly be in loss of life however I’m no longer definite it’s as drastic as John Nicholson suggests. Each person unruffled desires to commit it to memory, they’re gorgeous trying to attain it with the path of least resistance.

Unfortunately, tradition is the enemy of alternate and so the FA Cup will likely die agonisingly slowly alongside Test Cricket, Compact Discs and handbook gearboxes (I’d rather preserve the fundamental of those 2 for the document – no pun meant).

Those groups similar to Leicester who misplaced to underdogs didn’t gorgeous lose because they “circled their squad” – they took a calculated possibility which backfired. They didn’t residing out to lose and on paper unruffled will have to thrill in acquired. Man Utd also took a calculated possibility and on but some other day Reading would maybe well without say delight in beaten them with the positions they purchased themselves into. With the tip 2 divisions resting gamers it gorgeous makes it less complicated for the tip 6 as their reserve groups will in overall build away whatever is build up against them for the fundamental few rounds before they strengthen as they want to reckoning on their diversified practical trophy aspirations in direction of the discontinue of the season – search records from Metropolis & Liverpool to smash out to but some other top 6 or mid table premier league crew as and when they meet them whereas they focal point more on Premier league and Champions league – thus making it even less complicated for no doubt one of the vital diversified top 6 groups to have confidence the Cup.

The say IS about money (isn’t it continually?) however created by the sheer alternative of European and League video games that imply there is now not any longer a time to know the leisure seriously. If the premier league (and diversified divisions) were slice to 18 or sixteen groups then there can be time.

Money is rarely any longer going to permit that to occur and conserving up the proud traditions will prevent a total overhaul however the FA want to attain something differently. You would maybe launch by scrapping replays and time beyond guidelines and poke straight to penalties? Restrict top 2 divisions to gamers below the age of 23? Possibly a bigger overhaul as shown by the Uefa Countries league is the handiest methodology? Manufacture it 7-a-aspect football on a full field 30 minutes every methodology (sounds in fact dreary however see at T20 cricket and seven’s rugby)  Any diversified lustrous/dreary suggestions mailboxers?

The FA Cup isn’t ineffective, however for supporters of golf equipment in the tip divisions it gorgeous isn’t tantalizing until the Quarter Finals assuming your crew is unruffled there.
Jon, Cape Metropolis (however you continue to can’t beat the atmosphere at an FA cup recreation)


Wolves at the door
Managers picking weakened groups in the FA Cup, in strive and lift out eighth in its do of tenth in the premier league is The Biggest Chance Going through Football Nowadays™

Don’t let me down Nuno.
John Collins, WWFC, London


Iciness’s coming
I’m no longer being flippant when I question this, however why attain golf equipment poke for warm weather wintry weather practicing if they’ve a possibility one day of the wintry weather length (similar to United in Dubai)?

Is it gorgeous a crew bonding explain or is there a physiological reason for this? Assemble the gamers accept pleasure from resting up in a methodology that couldn’t be achieved at home (whereas also flying long distance and potentially tormented by jet paddle)?

In point of truth perplexed by it – it isn’t to find it irresistible can be warm (and even f*cking dry) anytime soon in Manchester, so it’s hardly ever love the gamers want to acclimatise. I interact there have to be a legit reason, gorgeous no concept what it’s.
Jack (January is an awful month and wants to be considerably shorter) Manchester


Shallow Puel
After the dust had settled on a grim afternoon for Leicester Metropolis and I had shared some maybe (potentially) hysterical views on Claude Puel my suggestions inevitably went to the deep situation of why will we attain this? Namely, what’s the point of being a football fan? (I did relate deep…).

I think the solution will vary for the tip four/5 however I landed on pleasure, expertise and hope. An exhilarating style of football (no longer basically gorgeous, however quickly paced, aggressive and something you may well also accept at the support of), the expertise that following your crew brings whether that be on TV or at the stadium and the hope that the crew improves and thus heightens the pleasure and expertise.

Right here’s the do my say with Claude Puel lies, he is doing very puny to raise on pleasure, expertise and hope. The style of football is unlucky. Very passive possession, an abundance of preserving midfielders and an isolated Vardy ends in dreary and turgid football. Being at Stamford Bridge and the King Vitality to beat Man Metropolis were amazing however in fact were the exception to the guideline – glimpse Cardiff three days later and loads of more. Playing a reserve aspect in the Carabao Cup (against a in fact beatable Man Metropolis 2d XI) and then almost a third crew against Newport effectively eliminated the hope of any expertise in cup competitions. Manufacture no bones about it a cup semi last can be the highlight of our season and something to be remembered – those crew choices were absolutely brutal for Leicester followers. Our season is effectively over, now we delight in Southampton subsequent Saturday and I couldn’t care much less. All now we want to see ahead to now is 1 or 2 league video games against the sizable boys which imply puny. I don’t delight in any beneficial hope this can alternate.

Puel is a nice man and I think he’s lustrous dapper with it, however as a football fan he is extremely hard to support. The most easy this looks to be to accept is finishing 7th-Ninth in the league yearly (Swansea three/4yrs in the past, Southampton 2/3yrs in the past) and that is something I gain very hard to accept enthusiastic in.
Dan, Herts


The identical old long time reader, first time writing in. My reason? No longer too definite. However it revolves across the FA Cup weekend. My first since transferring to London and I used to be excited. Unless it began. One of my chums is doing a ‘March to the Arch’, attempting to be aware a recreation from every round – which led me to joining in at the London Stadium to be aware West Ham play Birmingham.

The Irons went 1-zero up, took off the possibility that used to be linking all play in the last third, and then sat on the lead for the subsequent 70 minutes. Andy Carroll used to be handiest ever met with sarcastic cheers and “ineffective donkey/w*nker” at any time when he touched the ball. Which oddly used to be the loudest chant of the home crowd, other than the occasional performance by process of the Bubble blowing choir. However it used to be the Birmingham followers that truly hammered home the methodology I used to be feeling as I squinted at Andy Carroll flinging himself at every little thing and anything else in witness. After the ever predictable “is this a library?”, the away discontinue followed up with a refrain of “you’re no longer West Ham anymore”.

As I mirrored over the FA Cup weekend, I came to the conclusion that the mantra used to be potentially the saddest ingredient I witnessed all weekend. A weekend the do I sat in and watched Silver Linings Playbook on my maintain, used to be twice denied tickets from Loftus Road on Sunday because my flatmate and I ‘were no longer on the database’, and then persevered to fail in getting closing minute tickets to Craven Cottage. On the plus aspect, Pompey absolutely stuffed Norwich so taking a search ahead to the subsequent FA Cup weekend in the capital.
Max, Plastic Iron, Pointless QPR fan (?)


Teams of the season
Titillating that Damo has eschewed the two top scorers in the league for his early crew of the season in favour of three wingers (I’d poke with Auba).

As you’ll potentially receive tonnes of adaptations on a theme though, I cowl to you my alternative crew of the season:

GK – Etheridge

RB – Wan Bissaka
CB – Doherty
CB – Kabasele
LB – Digne

RW – Pereyra
CM – Doucoure
CM – Felipe Anderson
LW – Ryan Fraser

FW – Mitrovic
FW – Wilson
David (Gooner in Sheffield)


Dear MC

If we’re doing Teams of the First-1/2-Of-The-Season I concept I’d delight in a poke at a model for League Two.  With a concept to lend a hand followers of The Unswerving League In The World™ to thrill in a more in-depth see at our humble league, I’ve opted to ban myself to 1 participant from every crew – right here you poke.

For the formation, I’ll accede to the stereotype of lower league groups and take hang of a Mike Bassett style four-four-f***ing-two (nb – an awful lot of sides truly play a three-four-three or four-2-three-1)

GK – James McKeown, Grimsby Metropolis – maybe an surprising alternative however he used to be beneficial against my lot twice this season, and fearless against Palace in the Cup closing weekend

RB – Perry Ng, Crewe Alexandra – because as smartly as being a in fact gorgeous full support, he’ll be in a pub quiz come you as the “shortest authentic footballers surname without vowels”
CB – Krystian Pearce, Mansfield Metropolis – consistently beneficial at the centre of a support four that has handiest conceded 19 objectives to this point.
CB – Jordan Moore-Taylor, MK Dons – loyally followed his supervisor to the Franchise; surprisingly gorgeous in the air, reads the sport smartly, left footed, and takes an beneficial free kick.
LB – Danny Grainger, Carlisle United – a most modern full support in every sense, baggage of expertise, and already 5 objectives in 17 appearances this season from left support.

RW – Danny Mayor, Bury – Mayor has impressed me at any time when I even delight in seen him and for me is the beating heart of Bury’s thrilling front line – the Shakers lead the league in objectives.
CM – Michael Bostwick, Lincoln Metropolis – all gorgeous lower league groups need an enforcer and Bostwick combines an imposing physique with the clichéd “gorgeous toes for a wide man”.
CM – Sammie Szmodics, Colchester United – in overall plays gorgeous at the support of the forwards so Szmodics is given a free role to high-tail as the central playmaker of this aspect
LW – Keshi Anderson, Swindon Metropolis – consistently bad and continually ready to gain situation, we must at all times revel in this Palace youth product before he moves support up the leagues.

CF – James Norwood, Tranmere Rovers – the league top-scorer has tempo to burn and can revel in running on to the flickons acquired by the aim man, who’s clearly…
CF – Jayden Stockley, (handiest gorgeous left) Exeter Metropolis – the total top scorer for the calendar 300 and sixty five days 2018 in the English authentic leagues.  We’ll miss you Jayden.

Supervisor – Ticket Cooper, Forest Inexperienced Rovers – had sizable sneakers to own at FGR and the transition has been seamless, the return of Doidge up front makes them my darkish horse top tip for promotion to League One.
Terry Hall, Switzerland (averted the temptation to exclusively own this list with broken-down Grecians, however the four that are there are in on advantage I reckon)


As a Leicester fan (handiest crew diversified than Metropolis, Liverpool and Chelsea to accept a degree out in the questionably early ‘crew of the season’ to this point), I felt compelled to write in on Ricardo Pereira.

While he’s been very gorgeous no longer too long in the past, there are a number of causes he deserves to be nowhere come the RB field in crew of the season:

1. His easiest performances delight in come largely when he has been playing as a winger, in preference to an attractive-support

2. Early on in the season when he used to be playing at RB, he used to be at easiest inconsistent, however more accurately rather suspect. He misplaced his web page (justifiably) to Daniel Amartey before Amartey purchased injured.

three. Aaron Wan-Bissaka – This man has been a rock. Saw some statistics on him (can’t recall if it used to be on this web page or in other locations) this season, which confirmed gorgeous how advantageous he’s been. Anecdotally I’m lustrous definite he has achieved a beneficial job at containing any left sided attacking participant (glimpse Sane, Hazard) this season as smartly. I’m in a position to’t take into consideration anybody more deserving than the sphere than him. Possibly any individual with more time on their hands would maybe well dig some stats out to manufacture a better case than I even delight in.

Within the pursuits of a chunk more vary, some honourable mentions to a number of diversified gamers from the so-known as ‘lesser groups’ that have to be in the conversation; Callum Wilson (9 objectives, eight assists in the PL to this point, and a in fact feel-gorgeous comeback from afflict memoir total with the England call up – surely better than going with the false 9!), Ryan Fraser, Matt Doherty, Felipe Anderson, Richarlison, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang, Lucas Torreira
Ben(I roughly in fact feel contaminated for indulging this nonsense) LCFC 


Read More

Leave a Reply